Genie and Chamberlain are amongst the top five most used garage door openers in the US. With home security systems getting smarter with AI and Smart Voice assistant, choosing the right garage door opener has become a little taxing.
You may find your door opener fascinating with a smart voice assistant, but it might not be compatible with your old car. Similarly, some garage door openers may charge you extra for using them on a pay-as-you-go basis though they come with smart features.
Do Genie and Chamberlain have any such weak links?
We will discuss them in detail.
But before you decide to go with any particular brand, you must be aware of the basics first. It will help you select the right model. You can then compare similar models of the two brands based on their price, features and customer reviews to purchase the best one for your garage.
So, first, let’s start with small basic knowledge.
Types of Garage Door Openers
There are three types of garage door openers available under any brand you choose.
Chain Drive Opener
It is one of the most commonly available and used garage door openers. It operates with a chain connecting to a motor and a trolley. Due to this simple operating technique, this type of door opener is quite inexpensive and fits everyone’s budget. However, given the metal-to-metal contact during operation, the chain and trolley lead to loud noise and occasional vibration.
Belt Drive Opener
Belt-drive openers function the same way as a chain-drive opener, except they use a rubber belt in place of the metal chain. This brings down any noise or vibrations during the operation. Although a bit more expensive, the belt-drive openers are a smooth alternative to chain-drive openers.
Jackshaft Door Opener
These openers are installed at the door edges. A 24v DC motor drives the pulleys and cables to raise the door. Those who have tall door frames or want their ceiling free for overhead storage prefer the Jackshaft door opener over the others. However, due to the DC motor inside, they are expensive.
Now that you know the common types of a garage door opener let’s see what Chamberlain and Genie have to offer with each of these varieties.
Genie vs Chamberlain Garage Door Opener – Differences and Similarities
Both brands produce good quality garage door openers and have carried on their respective legacy forward for years to be fair. They offer openers from all the above-mentioned categories with a few similarities and differences to outsmart each other.
Let’s start with the similarities first.
Chamberlain vs Genie garage door openers: The Similarities
DC Belt Drive System with 3/4 HPS
Both Chamberlain and Genie use smart and efficient belt-drive systems to amplify their performance. The ¾ HPS DC belt drive system is robust and sturdy enough to lift the heaviest doors (up to 500 lbs and towering up to 8ft) quite effortlessly. The DC motor is smaller in size and quieter in performance than AC motors. Also, it uses the soft start and stop technique to draw less starting current than usual methods. Thus both Genie and Chamberlain score equal marks for their choice of motors.
If your garage is attached to your living space, its sound and vibration during operation can disturb housemates more often. However, both Genie and Chamberlain provide “ultra-quiet” or “noiseless” models to eliminate that problem in the first place.
The Chamberlain openers usually combine a steel-reinforced belt-drive with Chamberlain’s patent “Motor Vibration Isolation System” to easily bring down the powerhead vibration and noise.
On the other hand, Genie makes use of a 140V DC motor with a built-in soft start and stop feature. It guarantees a smoother and hence quieter operation; and is considered as a significant add-on to the DC motor.
When it comes to garage door openers, safety sensors bear the top priority. It stops the door from shutting on objects, people, or vehicles coming in between the door and the floor. Luckily, both the brands use sensors of the highest standard keeping their users’ safety in concern.
Genie uses an invisible beam across the door opening to alert users and reverse the door if the beam detects any blockage in the path. At the same time, Chamberlain models come with built-in safety sensors to stop the door from closing on obstructions.
Chamberlain vs Genie garage door openers: The Differences
Compatibility with Wireless Control Systems
In this regard, Genie has the upper hand as all its models readily sync with HomeLink and Car2U control systems. You don’t need any external tool like a compatibility bridge or a repeater box to connect your vehicle to the opener.
However, Chamberlain has limited compatibility with these control systems. Only new models are compatible, not the old ones. Plus, they only work if your vehicle runs on HomeLink 3.0 or above. If your vehicle is too old, you will have to invest in a repeater box to sync your car to the system.
But in case you have a brand new car with the latest tech, there should be no compatibility issue with your wireless control system from either Genie or Chamberlain.
With technological advancement, it’s not too much to ask for a smart garage door opener. In this regard, both brands offer garage door openers with several smart features.
Chamberlain’s MyQ Smartphone Control Technology allows you to monitor and control the opener from anywhere. You can give access to anyone from miles away using its native Android or iOS mobile application.
Similarly, Genie uses its proprietary Aladdin Connect application to turn its garage door openers smart. Unlike MyQ, Aladdin connect comes as an additional purchase to buyers, but its features are worth the money.
Those applications can check your garage door from the remote, set timers, and fetch you real-time notifications against any tamper. You can also authorize access to unlimited users and monitor their history of access as well.
Considering the above technical details, it boils down to your needs and future expectations out of a garage door opener. If you do not mind shedding a few extra bucks for elite smart features, Genie’s Aladdin Connect could be your ideal bet. But if you are good with basic smart controls, Chamberlain has a plethora of options to choose from.
Battery backup is one of the primary deciding factors while choosing any garage door opener. No one would like to be stuck inside or locked from outside the garage if the power goes off. So the smartest decision would be to go for models with battery backup.
Chamberlain models come with built-in battery backup. The unit keeps charging itself 24/7 from a power outlet. Whenever you face a power outage, the backup automatically kicks in to resume the operation.
Genie garage door openers do support battery backup as well. However, you will have to purchase the unit separately. This also adds to the overall cost of the opener system.
Durability (of motor)
Ideally, the motor for a garage door opener should have a lifespan of about 10-15 years, even though companies might provide a standard warranty for 3-5 years (Source). In the case of Chamberlain, the company provides a warranty for five years, but Genie extends the same to 10 years.
These similarities and differences that are listed above can only be used as a guideline. Both Chamberlain and Genie have their pros and cons, and you will have to look at their products closely and see which particular products meet the specifications you have in your mind.
Choosing a garage door opener on the basis of just the brand name is both unwise and unadvisable.
Both Chamberlain and Genie have their own pros and cons. It all depends on how much ease of use you want and that too on what level. However, there are two particular cases to take into consideration.
In case you have an old model car, go for Genie Garage door opener to bypass any compatibility issue. On the other hand, if you don’t want to spare single extra money on battery backup, go for any Chamberlain model as it is included with the purchase.
If none of these two factors are your concern, you can go with any of the two without giving any second thoughts.
Could you help us improve this article further? Drop your concerns in the comment box below. We will respond to your suggestions for sure!
Meanwhile, we hope this “Genie vs Chamberlain” article helped you choose the right garage door opener.